Langsung ke konten utama
QUORA
Do you know QUORA ???
Hello readers, i will share you about QUORA. At first, i
want to ask you, do you know about Quora??
Some people said Quora is a question-and-answer site where questions are asked, answered, edited and
organized by its community of users. it’s like social media but the
contain of Quora are questions and answers. All of the user can ask Question on
this application and also answer the Question on this site.
Last time, I used Quora and I found a good Question.
The Question is “Why would anyone want to be a doctor, given all the
discouragement by Quorans?”and
ithe best answer of this question is from “Christopher Fox”. He said “The answers you see are because the
profession has changed at least in the US. When I trained, my medical school
cost far less than my undergraduate school. Granted I went to my state
school vs MIT. But MIT was $8700 tuition then and my state medical school
was $2500 a year. I had a scholarship from Johns Hopkins APL
(because my father worked there for almost half the tuition of MIT). My
parents, $2500 a year in student loans, and $2000 a year in summer jobs paid
the rest at MIT. My costs to attend medical school were lower. So I
exited medical school with $17,500 in debt. I entered the lowest paid
residency in the country at $15,500 a year with $1000 increase per year so at
5th year I was getting paid $20,500. I had to moonlight in local ER's to
make ends meet but that meant I had a used car, apartment, and a boat. Fast
forward. Now my medical school costs $33,100 a year. Using a CPI
calulator it should be $5,427. That is over a 6 fold increase in cost at
just in my state medical school and private schools which I couldn't afford but
got into at the time have gone way up too. So now instead of a little
debt doctors get out with a medium sized house payment with student loan debt
averaging about $160,000-$200,000. Similar tuition inflation though not as
great as my medical school has been seen at most private universities.
Payments have fallen and insurance companies and the government dictate what
you get paid. You have an hour or two of paperwork/EMR to do every day
just to justify the payment. So many physicians have PA's or Nurse
practitioners work with them or hire another nurse.
While I was growing up insurance was called Hospitalization insurance. You
paid the doctor, and for your medicine. There were many fewer on
medicare and medicaid. These patient numbers on medicare and medicaid
have grown drastically and the insurance reimbursement to the physician has
fallen and is less or just at his costs today. So when I was growing up a
$30 payment for an office visit was the charge not the co-pay. He could spend
30 minutes with you. His malpractice coverage was a negligible amount.
Physicians used to be revered, now the patients see it as a right and that
doctors are "rich". No one begrudges the entrepreneur from
making $50 or $100 million dollars, but the average physician makes $220,000 a
year after 11-15 years of training. My son out of MIT with a BS and MEng
will make more than that after 4 years just starting out. Yes he is an
outlier in CS/EE and picked the perfect major. CS hardly existed when I
went to MIT. So when I went to school the best and brightest went into
medicine, law and business. Medicine was delayed gratification and you
could make a reasonable living and be respected in the community.
Personally, my malpractice carrier made $500,000 on me until I became
disabled. They left the field of medical malpractice stating in 37 years
in the business they had failed to make a profit in any year.
The loss of respect, expect for perfect outcomes, and lawsuits make the delayed
gratification with huge debt attached make medicine a much less appealing field
in the US. My two sons were explicitly told to not go into it by two
physician parents unless they really wanted to.
ETA: A comment requested I add about stress. There is more stress
than long ago. Malpractice risk is always on your mind. Physicians
drop privileges because of cost to insure themselves for those procedures
(adding spine coverage added $50,000 to my malpractice premium). Now we
are expected to document every single question asked or exam performed.
This takes time and slows us down. Finally we have to debunk internet
theories our patients come in with. So we are constantly being asked to
do more in less time. Add going out in the middle of the nights for
emergencies (which I signed on for) and our lives have markedly deteriorated in
the last 15 years. We no longer get to be a truly caring physician having
to rush, document etc. So many physicians have turned into test ordering
machines rather than diagnose by history and physical exam.”
Payments have fallen and insurance companies and the government dictate what
you get paid. You have an hour or two of paperwork/EMR to do every day
just to justify the payment. So many physicians have PA's or Nurse
practitioners work with them or hire another nurse.
While I was growing up insurance was called Hospitalization insurance. You
paid the doctor, and for your medicine. There were many fewer on
medicare and medicaid. These patient numbers on medicare and medicaid
have grown drastically and the insurance reimbursement to the physician has
fallen and is less or just at his costs today. So when I was growing up a
$30 payment for an office visit was the charge not the co-pay. He could spend
30 minutes with you. His malpractice coverage was a negligible amount.
Physicians used to be revered, now the patients see it as a right and that
doctors are "rich". No one begrudges the entrepreneur from
making $50 or $100 million dollars, but the average physician makes $220,000 a
year after 11-15 years of training. My son out of MIT with a BS and MEng
will make more than that after 4 years just starting out. Yes he is an
outlier in CS/EE and picked the perfect major. CS hardly existed when I
went to MIT. So when I went to school the best and brightest went into
medicine, law and business. Medicine was delayed gratification and you
could make a reasonable living and be respected in the community.
Personally, my malpractice carrier made $500,000 on me until I became
disabled. They left the field of medical malpractice stating in 37 years
in the business they had failed to make a profit in any year.
The loss of respect, expect for perfect outcomes, and lawsuits make the delayed
gratification with huge debt attached make medicine a much less appealing field
in the US. My two sons were explicitly told to not go into it by two
physician parents unless they really wanted to.
ETA: A comment requested I add about stress. There is more stress
than long ago. Malpractice risk is always on your mind. Physicians
drop privileges because of cost to insure themselves for those procedures
(adding spine coverage added $50,000 to my malpractice premium). Now we
are expected to document every single question asked or exam performed.
This takes time and slows us down. Finally we have to debunk internet
theories our patients come in with. So we are constantly being asked to
do more in less time. Add going out in the middle of the nights for
emergencies (which I signed on for) and our lives have markedly deteriorated in
the last 15 years. We no longer get to be a truly caring physician having
to rush, document etc. So many physicians have turned into test ordering
machines rather than diagnose by history and physical exam.” Thats true problem to become a doctor.
At last, thanks to read my blog J
Komentar
Posting Komentar